Meet Law Review’s Managing Editor Matthew Wagner ‘12
Matthew Wagner ’12 applied for a position on Law Review because he thought the experience would help his research and writing skills. Sure enough it has – “immensely,” he said. “Those skills are extremely important to practice, and if I hadn’t been on Law Review, I wouldn’t have had as much of a chance to improve those skills after 1L year,” Wagner said.
After working as an associate editor in 2009-10, Wagner is currently the Law Review’s managing editor, which largely consists of selecting the lead articles the staff publishes. These pieces are typically submitted by professors and practicing attorneys.
While Wagner said topic selection was the most difficult aspect of being on the staff as a 2L, he has embraced the opportunity, as a 3L, to review others’ articles. “I enjoy reading the different article submissions and seeing people’s ideas for how the law in a given area is evolving and learning more about different areas of law,” Wagner said. He has also enjoyed getting to know the other members of the Law Review staff, people he might not have had an opportunity to meet otherwise, he said.
In addition to his Law Review position, Wagner is also the chair of the Honor Council this year and has been involved with Out & Allies.
Wagner came to the College of Law after working a number of jobs, including a five-year stint at F+W Media, a publishing company at which he was involved with book production, purchasing, and logistics. “Since the publishing industry is imploding, it seemed like a good time to switch careers,” said Wagner, who had seen several of his friends graduate from law school straight from undergrad.
Wagner, who was born in Washington but moved east to Louisville at a young age, ended up in Cincinnati when he enrolled at Xavier University. He graduated from Xavier in 2001, where he was an English major and Theater minor. Wagner has been in the Queen City ever since. “I wanted to stay in Cincinnati if possible,” he said, when asked about his choice to attend the College of Law. “My wife’s family is here and my family is close by.”
In his free time, Wagner enjoys reading, playing video games, watching football, and simply socializing. But music, especially, is Wagner’s true pastime, and he writes music and also plays in a band. “I’ve been playing music my whole life – saxophone when I was younger and then guitar. It helps keep me sane,” he said.
Upon graduation and ultimately passing the Ohio Bar, Wagner will be working in the Labor & Employment group at the downtown office of Frost Brown Todd.
By Jordan Cohen, ‘13
For Executive Editor Sarah Topy Law Review is Opportunity to Cultivate Skills
Sarah Topy ’12 likes to stay busy. Any student or faculty member who has come in contact with her the past three years at the College of Law knows just that.
Topy, a 3L, is currently the chairperson of the Student Legal Education Committee (SLEC), and also has been doing research for Professors Marianna Bettman and Christopher Bryant for the past two years. In addition to those opportunities and her busy course load, Topy is also a member of Law Review, where she currently serves as its executive editor.
“We’re in here pretty much every day, weekends, during the breaks,” she said. “It’s a really big commitment and it takes a lot of time, but it’s worth it.”
Upon graduating from The Ohio State University in 2004, where she studied political science and creative writing, Topy spent several years working in politics. This included positions with John Kerry’s presidential campaign, the Ohio Democratic Party and with a congressional race in Chicago. After deciding to pursue a law degree, the Columbus native was attracted to the College of Law by its small size and also the comments made to her by a close friend, who earned his JD from UC in 2010.
While Topy has been and still is very busy with a number of activities and experiences, she has been devoting a lot of time to Law Review since joining the staff during the 2010-11 academic year.
Topy said three of her four section advisers during her 1L year were members of Law Review, which immediately piqued her interest. When she applied and received an invite to be part of the journal, Topy was “really excited” to join the staff.
“It’s nice, in addition to what you’re doing in the classroom, to be able to research and write in an area of law that you care about,” she said. “Plus, it is a collection of great students that you get to work with,” Topy said. “All of the people that are on Law Review are fantastic and smart and writing about really interesting topics.”
As an associate member of Law Review a year ago, Topy said she was “fortunate” to get published twice, once each semester. Her first article was a civil procedure topic on the State Secret Doctrine and her second one focused on Sharia Law and the First Amendment.
Since then, Topy was elected to fill the executive editor position for the current 2011-12 year. This requires doing the substantive editing for the journal, with both the lead authors and the student authors, for the various publishable pieces submitted. Topy said there are usually about five professors from across the country whose articles are selected for publication by the Cincinnati Law Review, and she works with these lead authors on their editing schedule.
“I really enjoy the opportunity to read and to learn about a lot of different areas of the law. The authors and the students that we publish are writing on complex and fascinating topics,” Topy said. “Also, just doing the editing and looking carefully at writing and making the writing as polished as possible helps me cultivate my writing skills. Obviously, that is a big part of being an attorney.”
In her free time, Topy enjoys reading fiction and is a big sports fan. In addition to cheering on her New England Patriots in the recent Super Bowl XLVI, the Ohio State graduate and Columbus native is also fan of, surprisingly, Michigan football!
Upon graduating from the College of Law in May, Topy will be working for Procter & Gamble, where she “had the incredible opportunity” of working last summer, she said. Topy was also a fellow at the Robert F. Kennedy Center for Human Rights in Washington, D.C., during summer 2010.
By Jordan Cohen, ‘13
Jeff DeBeer Finds Law Review Experience Mirrors Life
When given the chance to submit an entry into the Law Review write-on competition two years ago, Jeff DeBeer ’12 saw the journal as an opportunity to improve upon his research and writing skills.
“I tried out for Law Review, in part, because I thought I could have done better in my legal research and writing class,” he said. “I wanted to improve.”
Not only was DeBeer invited to join the Law Review, but he had a case note published as an associate member during the 2010-11 school year. It analyzed the effect of U.S. v. Doss on the federal witness tampering statute, § 1512(b),
After enjoying his Law Review experience as a 2L, DeBeer wanted to continue contributing to the publication as a 3L student. Thus, last spring he submitted a statement of interest to announce his candidacy for editor-in-chief, and he was eventually elected by his peers to serve in that capacity during this 2011-12 year.
“I ran for editor-in-chief for several reasons,” DeBeer said. “One reason is that the editor-in-chief gets to be a part of every aspect of running the journal, so there is a lot of group work and collaborative problem solving with bright, motivated students. Also, the editor-in-chief gains a lot of substantive editing experience.”
While being editor-in-chief certainly requires a significant time commitment, the St. Louis native has found it to be a very positive and even “fun experience so far,” he said.
Just last month, the Law Review launched a new website, which DeBeer credits to the work of Kenneth Hirsh, Director, Law Library and Information Technology and Professor of Practice, and the library staff.
The 2009 University of Kentucky graduate was also instrumental in establishing the Law Review’s new alumni advisory board, which was born out of the idea of holding an annual Law Review alumni banquet – the first of which is being held March 8 at the Millennium Hotel downtown.
DeBeer, a former member of the College’s Student Court, is also a member of the Trial Practice Competition Team and is a student member of the Inn of Court.
Of course, DeBeer spends most of his time outside the classroom in the third-floor Law Review office, working towards publishing the latest volume of the Cincinnati Law Review.
For the former UK political science major, getting the opportunity to work on Law Review to publish something that will be distributed to the legal community is a unique experience, unlike the typical submission of a term paper, DeBeer said. “When you’re putting your words, your opinions, your voice out (there), the level of detail and diligence required to make sure things are done properly mirrors what students on Law Review will have to do as attorneys,” DeBeer said. “The experiences gained while working on Law Review carry over into the student’s legal careers.”
DeBeer, who worked for a family law judge in Batavia and at the Northern Kentucky office of a Cleveland-based civil defense firm the last two summers, respectively, said he has aspirations to work in a litigation-oriented firm after graduating from the College of Law.
“As an end goal, hopefully somewhere down the line, I’d like to end up being a litigator, being in the court room and trying cases in front of juries,” he said.
Despite being extremely busy with classes, Law Review and the Trial Practice Team, DeBeer has made sure not to miss a single UK basketball game this season. The 3L said he “religiously” watches his alma mater, even if he has to watch on the Law Review television or on his computer when he cannot make it home in time to watch the Wildcats play.
DeBeer also enjoys playing basketball and running, as well as pleasure reading during breaks.
By Jordan Cohen, ‘13
University of Cincinnati Law Review Announces New Website, First Annual Alumni Banquet
The University of Cincinnati Law Review is pleased to announce that it has launched a new Website, which can be found at law.uc.edu/lawreview. The site contains past editions of the law review, current student casenotes and comments, and information about upcoming law review events.
"This is a great opportunity for us to share our scholarship, and the Website allows the Cincinnati legal community to learn more about the exciting work students are doing on Law Review," said Jeff DeBeer, Editor-in-Chief, '12.
In addition to posting law review articles online, the site will be used to reconnect with former law review members. The Law Review hopes to encourage alumni involvement through the Website and the newly created Law Review Alumni Board. "We hope that by going online, we can reach out to our alumni practicing in Cincinnati and beyond," said DeBeer.
Alumni can sign up for more information about events and networking opportunities here or by visiting the group's new Linkedin page. Additionally, the Law Review will be hosting its first annual Law Review Alumni Banquet, honoring former alumni and recognizing the efforts of current students.
This year's banquet will be held on Thursday, March 8 at the Millennium Hotel. At the banquet, the Law Review will honor former members Doug Dennis of Frost, Brown, Todd and James Helmer, Jr. of Helmer, Martins, Rice & Popham.
Another OIP Victory: Roger Dean Gillispie Released After 20 Years in Prison
Last week the OIP team was present to welcome home Roger Dean Gillispie from prison just in time for the holidays. Gillispie spent 20 years in prison after being convicted of three rapes in 1988. He was sentenced to 22-56 years in prison. For current and former OIP fellows this case was particularly special as it has the distinction of being the very first case the Ohio Innocence Project took on. On December 15, 2011 a federal judge in Dayton, OH threw out the conviction and on December 22 Gillispie was released.
Students who worked on the case over the years include current students: Caitlin Brown ’13, Chelsea Brint ’13, Megan Collard ’12, and Lindsey Fleissner ’12.
Some of the former fellows who worked on this case include: Mike Cappell ’05, Ashley Couch ’09, Miranda Hamrick ’09, Ryan Houston '11, Gerri Jones ’06, Melissa Laugle ’10, Jeanette McClellan ‘06, Darryl Osuch ‘11, Amanda Smith ‘10 and Kelly Schukart ’05, and Katie Stanberry ’06.
A History of Giving Back Leads 3L Ryan McGraw to the Law and the Linus Foundation
Although he cannot recall a specific moment in time when he became attracted to the law, Ryan McGraw ’12 said he has always wanted to be a lawyer. McGraw grew up in the Cincinnati suburb of Finneytown, before attending high school at nearby St. Xavier. It was during his four years of high school when McGraw developed an interest in serving others, and today he says his legal interests lie in the public sector.
“At St. X, our motto is ‘Men for Others,’ and I think that mindset has shaped my life since I graduated,” he said. “I have always felt called to give back in a meaningful way to those in the community who may be less fortunate than me, and I think it is for that reason that I hope to pursue a career in public interest law.” During his high school years, McGraw attended the American Youth Foundation’s National Leadership Conference (NLC), which he described as bringing together high school kids from across the country, to teach them leadership skills to take back to their communities and schools and make a difference.
“After I completed the four year program, I chose to return as staff, because of the impact that many of my mentors had on me throughout the program,” he said. “I hoped to make a difference in just one student’s life to the degree that my mentors had made on mine.” While at the NLC, McGraw struck up a friendship with a St. X graduate and eventual College of Law alumnus, Pat Hayes ’08, who told him about a non-profit organization he was working with in Cincinnati called the Linus Foundation. The Linus Foundation Cincinnati is a non-profit organization committed to providing service, care, and comfort to underprivileged children throughout the tri-state. Since the branch opened in 2008, Linus Cincinnati has donated thousands of dollars to local charities.
McGraw was “eager to get involved,” and has been very much so during law school, spending a lot of his free time fundraising and “trying to give back to the youth in Cincinnati.” In addition to Hayes, McGraw said John Treleven ’07 is also highly involved with the organization. “It has been tremendous to work with both of them and to get to know them on a personal level,” McGraw said. “It has also been extremely helpful to be able to discuss the challenges of law school and the legal economy with people who have been through the gauntlet recently.”
The Linus Foundation was recently able to donate $1,000 to St. Vincent de Paul, a non-profit social service agency that provides personal assistant with food, clothing, medicine, rent, utilities, transportation and companionship to people facing economic, emotional or spiritual crises. This donation was expected to pay for 22 beds for children who did not have one. Certainly, McGraw felt a sense of pride in knowing he was able “to make a difference” in those children’s lives.
Prior to attending the College of Law, McGraw majored in criminology and minored in real estate at The Ohio State University (with McGraw putting a special emphasis on the “The,” perhaps because he gave this interview just days prior to the annual Michigan game).
McGraw’s choice to attend the College of Law after his time at OSU was an easy one, aspiring to work for the Ohio Innocence Project. Not only did McGraw get an opportunity to work for the OIP last year, but he said his time as a fellow has been “by far the highlight of law school.” “In particular, working on the case of David Ayers, who was released in September after serving nearly 11 years for a murder he did not commit, was such an honor and privilege,” McGraw said. “Seeing him walk out of the county jail and spending the first moments of his freedom with him are things I will never forget.”
In his two-and-a-half years at the College of Law, McGraw has also been a part of Student Court, has served as a Student Ambassador, was president of the Law Republicans, was co-director of the Tenant Information Project, and currently is an articles editor for the Law Review.
When he is not busy with law school or helping others, McGraw enjoys spending time with family and friends, as well as golfing when he has a chance. The OSU graduate also “look(ed) for any excuse to go back to Columbus on Saturdays during the fall,” he said.
By Jordan Cohen, ‘13
Meet Missionary Turned Attorney: Scott Lewis ‘14
Like many of his peers, who similarly did not attend law school straight from undergrad, Scott Lewis has had a number of unique experiences and stories to tell. The 28-year-old, and eldest of five siblings, grew up in California and enrolled at Brigham Young University in 2002. He took off two years to be a missionary for his church and, along the way, became fluent in a Filipino language called Tagalog.
Lewis first heard of this language when he received the assignment from his church to serve a mission and began speaking this Austronesian language in June 2002. He had a “two month crash course” in the language, embracing the idea of needing to learn it to be able to effectively teach and serve during the mission, he said.
After a successful mission trip, Lewis returned to BYU where he pursued a political science degree. In the latter half of 2007, Lewis went abroad again, this time for an internship with the European Parliament in Brussels, Belgium. Lewis, who had previously taken a European Union class, inquired about potential internships and discovered a program offering a few positions.
“I took a semester long research and writing classes where we competed with about 40 or so other students,” Lewis said. “We were then selected based on work ethic, performance, speaking skills and teamwork. I was lucky enough to be selected to work with Kathy Sinnott of Ireland.” Sinnott is a disability rights campaigner and a former politician. She represented the South constituency in Ireland in the European Parliament from 2004 to 2009.
During his time in Belgium, Lewis’ attended many committee meetings, addressed constituent grievances and petitions, arranged meetings between environmental groups and the European Union Parliament, and wrote speeches, press releases, and also amendments alongside Sinnott.
Along the way, he was also able to indulge in some of Belgium’s finest foods. “Not only did I experience sitting in rooms with 20 languages going on all at once, but I got to eat at least 20 different kinds of chocolate,” Lewis said. “And waffles … good experience and great food."
After graduating from BYU in 2008, Lewis took a job with a bank as a teller, before working his way up to a loan officer in consumer lending. After befriending the bank’s general counsel, he was encouraged to attend law school – something he had considered before.
Lewis – a once active Assistant Scout Master – chose to apply to the College of Law at the recommendation of his cousin, who attend UC’s medical school. A number of factors led him to enrolling at the College, where he has been very busy but is enjoying his experiences thus far.
The California native has attended several Federalist Society meetings, has helped out with the Tenant Information Project, and has also been involved with Student Court. Lewis also has enjoyed attending various lectures on campus, while calling the Day of Service in September “a blast.” Further, Lewis has been inspired by his classmates and “love(s) talking with people here about what interests them,” he said.
Outside of school, Lewis has not been able to find much time for his interests in cycling and tennis. But the “happily married” 1L student is enjoying spending time with his three-month-old daughter, Grace, who he said “can smile and speak gibberish fluently.”
Lewis came to Cincinnati with a number of goals and aspirations, many of which are obviously academic- and career-oriented. Additionally, he and his wife set a goal of trying “all the major chili restaurants in Cincinnati." "So far,” Lewis said, “only Skyline has been tried.”
By Jordan Cohen, ‘13
From South Africa to Canada to the U.S.: 1L Clifford Lauchlan Found a Home at UC Law
As a member of the College of Law’s 1L class, Clifford Lauchlan will not be able to take the Client Counseling course for another year. But through his previous experiences, Lauchlan already has several years of practice working with people under his belt.
Lauchlan was born in Johannesburg, South Africa in 1982, before his family moved to Canada in 1992.
After receiving an English degree from Taylor College and Seminary in Edmonton, Alberta in 2005, he moved to Dayton and tied the knot on his long-distance relationship with then-fiancée, Leah.
That fall, Lauchlan took a job in the Career Services Department at Sinclair Community College in Dayton, working with high school students, displaced workers and other members of the community. Lauchlan was initially hired by Sinclair as a Career Development Technician. His job was to administer the “Discover Career Assessment” to juniors and seniors from Dayton area public high school.
In June 2006, he became a Career Development Specialist, utilizing “one-on-one counseling, workshops and presentations” to assist people who were considering a career change. While pursuing a master’s degree at the University of Dayton, Lauchlan completed a teaching assistantship, before returning to Sinclair as an adjunct faculty member.
By December of 2008, he found himself in yet another new role, serving as a counselor for displaced workers. “The most satisfying part of working with the displaced worker population at Sinclair was hearing the individual stories,” Lauchlan said. “The varied experiences, the hopes and concerns as they worked to forge a new future for themselves and their family were inspiring.”
But this was not the first time the now-29-year-old had been touched by the stories of individuals he had come to assist. While living in Edmonton, Lauchlan worked for five years at the Herb Jamieson Center, an all-male homeless shelter, which “slept between 160 to 230 individuals every night and served between 300 and 400 individuals at each meal.”
He began working a midnight to 8:00 a.m. shift on his 18th birthday. Although he worked on a part-time basis when he started college courses, he worked full-time during the summers and on breaks. “It was a defining experience,” Lauchlan said. “Again, the most memorable aspect of this experience was hearing the individual stories.
“From individuals who had lost it all through no fault of their own, to others who had squandered opportunities through a series of poor choices, ‘the Herb’ afforded a fascinating glimpse into life for an 18-year-old to see the world from new and different perspectives.”
While working at the downtown Edmonton shelter, Lauchlan regularly interviewed new individuals, getting to know them and screening them for noticeable issues, he said. “During the interview process, the clients would tell me how they came to be in the situation they were in,” he said. “This was a priceless education.”
Prior to moving to the United States, Lauchlan also joined the Canadian Infantry Reserves. After spending the week in his classes, Lauchlan trained on the weekends. However, he left the Reserves prior to moving to the States. Although he only had the opportunity to train, he is “thankful” for the experience he did have.
While enjoying life in the United States, Lauchlan initially planned to become an English professor. After completing his master’s at the University of Dayton, he decided to pursue a different career path that would allow him to use his skills in research and writing: the law.
Lauchlan was accepted by both law schools to which he applied, UC and Ohio State, but the decision to come to the College of Law was a fairly easy one for him. In addition to liking the size of the College of Law, he found Cincinnati to be the “more interesting city,” and he said he would like to work in the Queen City after graduation.
Thus far, Lauchlan is enjoying each of his classes, in addition to being the co-president of the College’s Federalist Society, he said.
He is also juggling his time as a student with being a parent, as his wife gave birth to their first child, Ian, back in February. If becoming a father and beginning law school were not enough excitement for Lauchlan, he recently won second place and a $3,000 scholarship for an essay he wrote, entitled “The Emperor’s New Clothes: Behaviorism and the Threat of Central Control.”
By Jordan Cohen, ‘13
College of Law Bar Exam Results Continue to Be Strong
University of Cincinnati College of Law Bar Exam Results Continue to Be Strong
The bar results for University of Cincinnati College of Law students who took the July 2011 Ohio Bar Exam are in and the College of Law, once again, made a strong showing. UC Law ranked first in the state for overall test takers with a passage rate of 92 percent. This can be compared to an overall passage rate for all takers of 81.6 percent.
In addition, the passage rate for the College of Law’s first-time test takers was 94 percent, up from 91 percent last year; placing UC’s law students first among Ohio law schools for first-time test takers, sharing the spot with the Ohio State University. The passage rate for all first-time takers in Ohio was 86.1 percent.
Applicants who successfully passed the examination and satisfied the Ohio Supreme Court’s character and fitness screening were sworn in on Monday, November 7 at 10:30 a.m. during a special session of the Supreme Court at the historic Ohio Theatre in Columbus, OH. The session was streamed live via the Supreme Court and Ohio Channel websites at www.supremecourt.ohio.gov and www.ohiochannel.org. It is available statewide on the Ohio Channel’s local public broadcasting stations.
The Ohio bar exam lasts two and a half days and is comprised of 12 essay questions, two Performance Tests, and a day-long multiple-choice Multistate Bar Examination. The bar exam is administered by the Supreme Court, which regulates the practice of law in Ohio, including the admission of new attorneys, the biennial registration of current attorneys, attorney discipline in cases of misconduct, and the administration of continuing legal education.
Photo: 2011 graduate Sarah Leibel
Patent Law Interest Leads Jared Brandyberry ’11 to Geneva, Switzerland
Jared Brandyberry decided to attend law school during his senior year at UC, when he became interested in intellectual property. “Patent law interested me because it mixed my technical background with the law and allowed me to work with entrepreneurs and innovators developing new inventions,” the 2011 College of Law graduate said.
Today, that interest in IP has the lifelong Cincinnatian working halfway across the world for the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) in Geneva, Switzerland.
Brandyberry grew up on the eastside of Cincinnati in Anderson Township. He graduated from UC in 2008, where he majored in biochemistry before pursuing his law degree. With an interest in staying in Cincinnati, combined with being the recipient of the James B. Helmer, Jr. Scholarship, attending the College of Law was an easy choice for Brandyberry.
After his 1L year, he began focusing on IP and patent law. Brandyberry mentioned Ed Acheson, Jim Liles, Ria Schalnat, Steven Goldstein and Lori Krafte as “great adjunct professors that did an excellent job of incorporating their extensive (IP) experience into the course material.”
While at the College of Law, Brandyberry was a member of the Intellectual Property Law Society, in addition to his involvement with the Entrepreneurship and Community Development Clinic (ECDC).
During his first summer, Brandyberry worked at UC’s Intellectual Property Office, focusing on prior art searches and licensing agreements. The following summer he went to the Washington D.C. area to work for the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
Brandyberry also did a legal externship with Baker Hostetler in their patent division, a judicial externship with Judge Sandra Beckwith of the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, and an internship with Professor Lewis Goldfarb at the ECDC.
During the fall semester of his 3L year, Brandyberry applied to the WIPO, which is a United Nations agency that oversees the international IP system. The following semester, he was offered (and later accepted) a temporary position with the Patent Cooperation Treaty division (PCT).
“I took the bar in Ohio the last week in July, drove home on that Thursday and then flew to Geneva on Friday to get an apartment and start work on Monday, August 1,” he said.
The PCT, which established an international patent filing system with 144 contracting states, Brandyberry said, has more than 160,000 PCT applications filed annually “by applicants hoping to protect their inventions in multiple nations.”
“My team issues advisory opinions on the Articles and Regulations of the PCT for receiving offices,” Brandyberry said. “In addition to different advisory opinions, I am also working on multiple studies which may result in proposed amendments to the PCT.”
His first contract with the WIPO was for three months, with an option to continue through January, he said. As of now, he is unsure whether a full-time position will be available, in addition to the uncertainty as to whether his friend with whom he is living will be able to continue working out of P&G’s Geneva office.
While Brandyberry is interested in staying there if he gets a full-time offer, he otherwise would “plan to return to Cincinnati and work in the IP field.”
Brandyberry, who called it “an amazing opportunity to live abroad” while getting exposure to patent law internationally, is enjoying life in – and outside – of Geneva. “The best part about living in Geneva so far is that’s centrally located and connected to an excellent rail system, which makes travelling through Europe very easy,” he said.
Certainly being far removed from Cincinnati, the place he has called home outside the one summer in D.C., has been an adjustment for Brandyberry. He said he misses his friends and family the most, of course, but also misses going to Bengals and Bearcats football games.
Brandyberry also mentioned that prices are a bit more reasonable back home. “(Here), it’s about $7 for a Grande coffee at Starbucks,” he said.
By Jordan Cohen, ‘13